Listen here.
This is in response to criticism from Tavis before the last audio file I posted.
My favorite line is…”I’ll call Tavis, because I definitely don’t enough to do with running for President.” lol
Tavis needs to stop.
UPDATE: When Senator Obama mentioned that he couldn’t attend he offered to have Michelle Obama be there in his place and Tavis declined to have her stand in for him! Initially, I thought Tavis just had his feelings hurt that Obama wasn’t attending, but this is beyond that. Tavis is straight up hatin’.
According to the Chicago Sun-Times, here is the letter Barack Obama sent:
February 13, 2008
Mr. Tavis Smiley
President and CEO
The Smiley Group
3870 Crenshaw Boulevard
Suite 391
Los Angeles, CA 90008Dear Tavis,
Thank you for the invitation to participate in the 2008 State of the Black Union forum in New Orleans, Louisiana February 21-23. The exchange of ideas raised at this annual symposium are invaluable as our nation strives to address the critical issues facing not just African Americans, but Americans of every race, background and political party.
I especially commend you for hosting this dialogue in New Orleans. On the eve of the Louisiana primary, I visited this great city for the fifth time since declaring my candidacy to share policy proposals for rebuilding the Gulf Coast so that we never experience another Hurricane Katrina. On February 9, I was deeply humbled to win the Louisiana primary with 86 percent of the African American vote and a 14 point lead among all voters who said they were adversely affected by Hurricane Katrina.
Uniting our country and creating a national constituency for fundamental change is why I am running for President of the United States. We have come a long way in this race, but we still have a long road ahead. In the final stretch, I will be on the campaign trail everyday in states like Ohio, Texas and Wisconsin talking directly with voters about the causes that are at the heart of my campaign and the State of the Black Union forum such as affordable healthcare, housing, economic opportunity, civil rights and foreign policy. I am committed to touching every voter, and working to earn their vote.
That is why with regret, I am not able to attend the forum. I understand that you have declined the campaign’s request to have Michelle Obama speak on my behalf. I ask that you reconsider. Michelle is a powerful voice for the type of real change America is hungry for. No one knows my record or my passion for leading America in a new direction more than Michelle Obama.
Tavis, this is our movement and our time. I look forward to working closely with you throughout this election. Thank you for your continued support.
Sincerely,
Barack Obama
UPDATE: You can read Tavis’s response to this controversy here.
February 15, 2008 at 10:37 am
Hey Sagereader,
Barack’s quote should read, “…I definitely don’t have enough to do…”
I was confused until I listened to the audio link.
Thanks
February 15, 2008 at 11:32 am
hey, thanks william. i just corrected that.
February 15, 2008 at 12:30 pm
I agree!
This is just pure, unadulterated HATE by Mr. Smiley!
I am glad to see Barack’s campaign go on offense, and push their side of this story.
Here is a link of Michelle Obama discussing this issue on Michael Baisden’s show:
http://www.zshare.net/audio/7550880511202f/
Do you think Tavis would decline if Bill Clinton offered to fill in for Hillary?
February 15, 2008 at 4:16 pm
Tavis of all people is pulling this mess?
You’re making yourself look bad, player.
I’m appalled at this. Black people, y’all gotta understand that running for president is an extremely time consuming and energy draining endeavor - please look past this nonsense.
This campaign is obviously at its most critical stage when every single second is carefully planned for.
Is this a possible swiftboat attempt in the works from the Smiley Group? it’s a scary thought.
February 15, 2008 at 5:45 pm
Tavis better be careful. He lost his job on BET does he want to lose PBS also!
February 16, 2008 at 12:25 am
Yes, I think Tavis’ days are numbered on PBS. They were about to cancel his show prior to all of this, but he used the race card. This is truly not good on Tavis’ part. He is a loose cannon with an oversized ego, which is not a good combination.
February 16, 2008 at 2:33 am
I must admit that I’ve seen Tavis’ show maybe twice ever. When he was on BET, I didn’t have cable so I never saw that. I’m not a huge television watcher anyway.
But I decided to mosey on over to Tavis’ website to see if he was addressing these accusations, and sure enough, he was. I suggest others do that as well because what he is saying does not correlate with what the whole daggone internet is saying, is that is disturbing. I look for “truth” in all that I do, and I’ve read story after story about this topic. My first thought was, “Damn. This bamma is arrogant as shit.” But I kept on reading the anger and folks cussing him out, and the one that really got me was a woman on this blog saying that she hates Tavis for this, in ALL CAPS at that. I thought that was pretty intense, and pretty unnecessary, and definitely ugly. So I decided, as I always do, to seek out the “other side” of the story.
With that said, here’s Tavis’ side of this divisive story:
http://tavistalks.erban.com/TJMS_021408_mp3.html
And here’s the transcript, just in case you don’t have speakers or Quicktime:
http://tavistalks.com/pdf/ts_obama_commentary_a.pdf
Personally, I think he puts the issue to rest, whether people like that or not. lol
February 16, 2008 at 9:14 pm
Tavis,
Please ask Hillary what she plans to do about unequal justice. I notice that she seems to avoid the subject. It seems she just doen’t want to touch it.
February 16, 2008 at 11:28 pm
http://unbohio.blogspot.com/2004/10/tavis-smiley-is-hypocrite.html
February 17, 2008 at 4:56 pm
Tavis is just another Clinton attack dog, I never like him and I will never like him. Here is who I like Dr. Boyce Watkins his view on this issues http://www.youtube.com/v/fUsdBZwvE-U&rel=1
February 17, 2008 at 11:00 pm
TAVIS I WAS DEEPLY HURT AT THE WAY YOU’RE TREATING THE OBAMA FAMILY MICHELLE OBAMA IS A GREAT SPEAKER, YOU SHOULD BE PROUD TO HAVE HER PINCH HIT FOR HER HUSBAND. (SHAME ON YOU) I WOULD HAVE NEVER THOUGHT YOU THAT YOUR HEAD WOULD BECOME LARGER THAN YOUR BODY!
February 17, 2008 at 11:02 pm
PLEASE COME BACK TO THE LITTLE PEOPLE, WE WILL WELCOME YOU WITH OPEN ARMS! GOD BLESS ALL!
February 17, 2008 at 11:07 pm
MAY YOU HAVE GOD’S CONTINUED BLESINGS!
February 18, 2008 at 11:28 am
I think a lot of US are missing the point of having the “State of the Black Union” in the first place. This is where WE ask people in power and who want to be in power what their position is on issues thst affect US. The forumm is open to ALL the canidates to attend. I wish all of them would choose to attend and aire their view points on OUR conserns. That being said, Why should Sen. Obama be given a pass on attending this forum? He says he wants to be a canidate of all the people of this great country, but won’t come to N.O. to be a part of and address the issues that will be raised during the conference. Just because Tavis has a different take and want to hold ALL those who seek to be the president to the same standard, He is called a “hater”, how childish to think like this. We really over-use that word “HATER” too. If someonehas a different oppinion than yours or mine for that matter, Why do they have to “be hattin on me”?
Can’t we just have two or three ways of looking at something.
I too think Mrs. Obama is an excellent speaker and would do a excellent job speaking at the SBU,if that was what was called for, just making a speach. However, this gives black america the chance to be the judge of each person asking for our vote this election. Would you send a stand-in before the judge if this were a courtroom instead of this type of forum? I bet the judge would be dissapointed and would not hesitate to show his displeasure with you for sending someone else,
Or would he “just be Hatin on you” too
February 18, 2008 at 12:56 pm
Lionel, do you have a specific question about Obama’s policy positions that he has not already addressed?
February 18, 2008 at 1:40 pm
Mr. Smiley is like many “so-called” black leaders and commentators who hitched their wagon early on to the Clinton express. I don’t know what he was promised by her campaign, but he has been disparaging Senator Obama from the start. Prior to the South Carolina primary he referred to blacks who would vote for Obama as “black bourgeois” who don’t care about the black struggle (on the Tom Joyner Morning Show). He has continued to lambast Senator Obama, while giving Senator Clinton a pass. It is clear that he does not like Senator Obama and that he was not expecting him to do this well.
Here is a quote from Smiley that indicates his feelings towards Senator Obama:
“The other thing is that Barack Obama has not had the quintessential black experience in America - raised in Hawaii, spent time in Indonesia, biracial family. He didn’t grow up in Mississippi or the South Side of Chicago. Most black folk got to know Barack the same way white folk got to know him - two years ago when he gave that speech at the Democratic Convention. Barack Obama is no Jesse Jackson. For that matter, Barack Obama is no Shirley Chisholm. When Shirley Chisholm ran in ‘72, when Jesse ran in ‘84 and ‘88, they had long-standing relationships with the black community. So there’s some courting here that Barack is going to have to do. I don’t know whether or not, after the courtship, if black America is going to decide that we’re going to date, much less be wed to him. ”
I guess Barack Obama is not black enough for Mr. Smiley. I guess the fact that he has a white mother offends Mr. Smiley and that somehow Senator Obama has to prove that he is indeed truly black. I guess Senator Obama has to be born in Mississippi or the South Side of Chicago in order to be a true black man according to Mr. Smiley’s assessment.
It’s no wonder that Senator Obama doesn’t feel any obligation to attend the Tavis Smiley promotion event (the State of the Black Union). Why should he, when the host shows clear hostility towards his campaign? He does have better things to do!
If Mr. Smiley wants to truly affect the “State of the Black Union”, I suggest that he have the courage to run for President instead of wasting time pontificating. This “get together” called the State of the Black Union has done nothing to improve conditions in the African-American community. It is just another self-promotion event for these do-nothing alleged black leaders and commentators.
If we truly want to improve the State of the Black Union we need to look inward and start with ourselves, instead of expecting one “Black Messiah” to lead us to the promised land. Senator Obama is running for the Presidency of the United States. If he were to go to a singular focus on my race (African-American) I wouldn’t vote for him. The country as a whole needs healing, and pandering to one race is not going to heal us.
With that said, if Senator Obama wins the presidency I believe that we will see an improved state for African-Americans.
February 18, 2008 at 2:36 pm
“With that said, if Senator Obama wins … we will see an improved state for African-Americans.”
I agree because Obama is not one of the ever-present latter day tribal chieftains set to send brothers and sisters and mothers down the river for some jewels and some guns (with no gunpowder), not one of the modern day house slaves all too willing to talk to Massa about what the field negros are doing in exchange for an extra hamhock.
No, like Dr. Eric E. Williams said in Trinidad & Tobago a half century ago: MASSA DAY DONE!!!
February 18, 2008 at 4:13 pm
I have lost all respect and admiration for Tavis..I heard his follow up commentary to this interview on the same venue and yes he was angry. I don’t think its a matter of him being concerned with Obama as a candidate that cares about black american issues..I feel he is just hateful and resentful of Barack Obama. He like so many I feel is just milking the whole poverty issue in the black community and not really making changes that matter.
February 18, 2008 at 5:17 pm
I regret that Tavis has chosen to belittle Senator Obama. While I respect the fact that he does not have to support his candidacy, his insults are unacceptable.
Last year when Tavischose to belittle Senator Obama for not announcing his candidacy at the meeting, I thought how naive or was it just plain ego. But as time has progressed and many others that appeared on his show have chosen to support Senator Obama, I am resigned to the fact that the dislike is plain ego.
Perhaps Tavis and Bob Johnson should appear together, since they have both embarrassed themselves.
Rest assured that I will boycott Tavis this year.
February 18, 2008 at 7:09 pm
Smiley is a hater. Obama will be President, that simply. Change is coming my people!!
February 19, 2008 at 12:15 am
As an informed African-American, Tavis Smiley is not my spokesperson. I do not agree his program is the solution. I don’t agree Obama has to attend to legitimize himself with black people. I think Obama’s apperance only adds credibilty to Tavis’ program.
Barak Obama needs to stay focused on his agenda moving forward and those of us who are forward thinking need to do our thing to help. If yo ain’t helping get out of the way.
Tavis has made a lot of money TALKING to black people. Enough said, cause I don’t want to out him and start hating on him.
February 19, 2008 at 12:25 am
Mr. Smiley seems to embody the moniker we sometimes use to describe folks and that is he is a “poverty pimp.” He is one who has made a living purporting to be a fighter and warrior for the cause of the downtrodden Black race in America. It may have escaped me so someone please tell me his long standing credentials on actually doing something to change America other than talk?
Has he been a supporter of the Innocence Project to get wrongly convicted men, the majority of whom are Black, off death row with DNA evidence? Has he tried to get a poor family the public services that they can’t get for themselves/
What the hell has he done to question the commitment of Senator Obama. Does he even fathom the act of courage that his mere candidacy displays to the world. The “audacity” of a Black man to think he can be President of these United States of America when they killed Martin for just wanting equal access. He and his family are out there for us with all the sickos in this world, they are truly courageous.
What have you done Mr. Smiley to put yourself in harms way for the cause of the Black and downtrodden people of America? Sticking a damn microphone in your hand on a stage or in a studio doesn’t count…
February 19, 2008 at 11:55 am
I THINK THAT THIS SHOWS THAT OBAMA IS FOR EVERYONE, NOT JUST THE AFRICAN AMERICAN OR DEMOCRATS, ETC. THE MAN IS ON A MISSION, AND AN INVITATION IS JUST THAT. IT CAN EITHER BE ACCEPTED OR DECLINE. I DON’T THINK THAT OBAMA IS SAYING THAT, “AFRICAN AMERICAN CONCERNS ARE NOT IMPORTANT”, BUT HE IS SAYING THAT HE WANTS TO REACH EVERYONE. ACCORDING TO HIS LETTER TO TAVIS, HE HAS BEEN TO LOUISIANA ON SEVERAL OCASSIONS PRIOR TO THIS INCEDENT, SO HE DOES CARE ABOUT THEIR CONCERNS. ATTENDING THE BLACK STATE OF THE UNION
FORUM WILL NOT OPEN OBAMA’S EYES TO THE FEELINS OF EVERY AFRICAN AMERICAN OR AMERICANS PERIOD, BUT BY SPENDING THAT TIME OUT ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL HE CAN HEAR MORE PEOPLE AND TOUCH MORE LIVES.
February 19, 2008 at 2:04 pm
I am so saddened to hear yet again of black people hating on each other. I have lost respect for Tavis, and hope that he reconsiders and allows Michelle Obama to appear in Barack’s place. We may never get another chance for a brilliant Black man such as Barack to get this far in the political process. He has a terrific chance of winning because ALL ethnicities find him appealing! I have attended one of his rallies, and the mood is electrifying. While at his rally, I was able to speak with young/old, white, black, latino, and they are all excited about him and believe that he is the one who can change America, ending partisan politics once and for all. Yes, he is the one we have been waiting for, and Tavis for whatever reason, is trying his best to set him back. I believe it is finally time to check all ego’s at the door!
February 19, 2008 at 5:00 pm
WHAT DOES TAVIS WANT? WHY DIDN’T HE RUN FOR PRESIDENT?
HE HAS A LOT OF MOUTH IS ALL THAT I HEAR OVER THE YEARS FROM
MR. TAVIS SMILEY?
February 20, 2008 at 2:09 am
Tavis,
I’m glad you’re not a member of Barack’s strategy team!!
February 20, 2008 at 8:01 am
Someone said it right earlier, Tavis Smiley is a Poverty Pimp! He hitched his wagon to the Clintons long ago, so his dog of “being unbiased” won’t hunt.
I’m so done with Tavis. He’s done himself a world of damage on this one..he , Bob Johnson and Shirley Lee should embrace and skip off into the sun set…
February 20, 2008 at 10:07 am
Tavis needs to understand that this election is bigger than “Tavis Smily” or the (State of the Black Union) symposium. Shut up and do something,
February 20, 2008 at 10:27 am
Tom and Sybil need to check themselves too. I was offended by the fact that Tom asked Barack to call Tavis, Maxine Waters, Andy Young and Magic Johnson and try to woo them over and win their support. Barack does not have to pander to these poverty pimp, house negroes. His answer was perfect! It’s not like I have nothing better to do. Right on brother. Chi-town in the House!!!! This is all about the fact that Jesse, Al, Maxine, Andy Young and house negroes are not in Barack’s inner circle. He doesn’t owe them anything and they are rabid by it. As President of the United States, you have to put forth public policies that benefit ALL Americans. Not blacks, latinos, poor people etc. If poor people would get off their asses and educate themselves and stop looking for somebody like Tavis to give them feel good rhetoric they’d be much better off.
February 20, 2008 at 1:28 pm
This Tavis guy sounds like he needs help. What a horribly written letter….
What an idiot!
February 20, 2008 at 1:51 pm
Barack Obama is an organizer and understands that running for President of the USA requires that one not discriminate or even suggest leaning toward any person, group, program or situation. Success in any leadership position depends on how effective the organizing team performs. Remember Barack is an organizer. His successful campaign efforts is evidence of his organizational skills.
February 20, 2008 at 5:20 pm
I’ve noticed that Tavis has been hating on Barack for the last few weeks. This was in January. He was very negative about Barack with a David Gergen interview. I was surprised but I knew then that he was a Hillary man. He implied that Hillary was a far more savvy and prepared candidate than Barack Obama. Look at his podcast if it is available. It was about two weeks ago. Tavis is sponsored by Wal-Mart and Hillary has Wal-Mart ties so maybe they have a common bond, maybe she was helpful with this sponsorship or maybe he’s just a supporter (which is all alright ). If he wants to be a help to Black folks I would suggest that he not torch bridges with any candidate. Even the losers can be helpful.
February 20, 2008 at 5:49 pm
V.P.
Beautifully said!
February 20, 2008 at 11:12 pm
Brother Tavis, I have wrote you before concerning a personal interest. You didn’t even give me the common decensy to write me back. At least Barack responed to you. Fair exchange is no robbery. What you do to people has it’s way of coming back to you. It’s a we thing , not a me thing. We the black man is the surpreme fittess of humanity. But, it’s a human race not a color race. That is why Barack is going to WIN the race. His vision is much broader than yours. Yes! I’m as BLACK as we get. We must set the stage for all races of people to follow. I am proud of Barack for doing that. I’m sure that I won’t hear from you again. Peace & Love, King Ayettey Zubaidah
February 20, 2008 at 11:40 pm
I think it’s very unfortunate that Tavis Smiley has not decided to support Obama. Though Obama may not have grown up in Mississippi or in any other primarily black area. He has definitely experienced more than Hillary Clinton because as they say you can’t hide the skin you are in. Tavis should understand that Obama is trying to win a presidential election where he will need the black vote and then some. As long as he is addressing the issues of our community, which I believe he has, it shouldn’t matter what he attends. Now, if it’s true Obama didn’t send the letter to Tavis and just posted it on the internet I do take some offense to it. I would think Obama could at least send the man the letter directly or call him personally and let him know that he wouldn’t be attending and see if his wife could attend in his place. I personally don’t think that is too much to ask.
Lastly, though I am disappointed a little bit with Tavis Smiley I don’t think we should run him under the bus, per se. The man has still brought a lot of issues to the table that others were scared to talk about and overall I think he is still an asset to the black community even if our opinions differ in some areas. I think we should keep this in mind before we decide that he is no longer relevant, or is a traitor, etc… Punish him for the thinks he’s done wrong but give him credit where credit is due as well.
February 21, 2008 at 12:51 am
BARACK AND MOCHELLE OBAMA ARE UP AGAINST SOME VERY POWERFUL FORCES. HIS CANIDACY IS VERY INSPIRING BUT TENUOUS. WE AS AFRICAN-AMERICANS MUST BE WISE AND UNDERSTAND THAT THE DEEP ROOTED RACIAL PSYCHOSIS IN AMERICAN CAN’T BE HAP HAZARDLY DISTURBED FOR THE SAKE OF OUR PERSONAL DESIRES AND VANITY. ALLOW OUR BROTHER TO GET IN POSITION TO HANDLE THE 800 LB GORILLA OF HISTORIC AND SYSTEMIC RACISM. HE MUST WIN AT ALL COST.DO NOT DISTURB HIM, OUR ANCESTORS ARE WATCHING US.
February 21, 2008 at 2:36 am
It’s absolutely amazing that there seems to be little - sensitivity from the Smiley group as to the scheduling and planning that has to take place, almost dynamically in a campaign camp.
Now you can bet that Hillary will show up…and she WILL SHOW UP; but that is the same lobbying that is done to bribe and influence votes and she plays the game well…are we still going to allow ourselves to be played is the question. There will be nothing heartfelt there, nothing that isn’t very strategic and planned…and I almost guarantee you … there will be 0 to no follow up, IF SHE WERE TO BE ELECTED.
Is there no insight and understanding by the black populace, that though Barack isn’t reveling - for us - in the lime light, and verbalizing positions that will be addressed concerning us specifically - that his self, his mirrored nature, the example of his entire life be-speaks the dedication and emotional investment HE HAS shown throughout his life in the concerns and struggles of Black people…? Can we not understand the almost psychological necessity in being and following through as the “Man for the people…” because we know that others are watching? And I’m not selling out - just because I’m not SHOUTING_OUT……..doesn’t make me a traitor, nor unconcerned…Barack, doesn’t want to blow it for us…ALLLLLLL of us. But if he alienates any - his threads of base will wane…and WE need to be insightful enough and connected enough, and 21st century enough to know when it’s time to display - Quiet eloquence….and deliver trust, and hope: where there were and could still be NONE YET…We have this opportunity to Change things IRREVERSABLY……..If we just get calm…and see with your eyes and minds and not just our emotions…….Change is here……and we have this opportunity with our voices and votes - to make that change count, clear - decisive.
February 21, 2008 at 9:18 am
It always amazes me how people change their arguments depending on the issue or person at stake. When Republican candidates refuse to attend debates or black forums, we all agree that it is because they don’t care. When Obama does it, we say that he is too busy with other matters and we give him a pass. We blame Tavis Smiley instead. This is way too ridiculous. Why on earth should Tavis allow Michelle to speak for Obama? The SOBU is an avenue for CANDIDATES to tell us their agenda for black America, so as brilliant as Michelle is, she is NO substitute. She is simply a spouse. Are we so hungry to elect a black candidate that we will now diss Tavis who has done nothing all his life but push forward the agenda of black people? So, what if he supports Hillary, why does that now all of a sudden make him a sellout. You folks are ALL unbelievable. Should we all vote for Barack because he is black and we are black? Hasn’t our maker blessed us with the brains to think for ourselves and make our own decisions based on our individual perspectives and should we not respect that in everybody? Do we have to hold Obama to a different standard because he is black and say it is OK for him to pass on SOBU because he has more important things to attend? Give me a BREAK.
February 21, 2008 at 9:42 am
Let Tavis rant and rave all he wants. Not to say he hasn’t consistently raised issues that we all care about and need to pay attention to — and his State of the Black Union is a very real opportunity to bring those issues to the table. I believe he is incredibly passionate about seeing all people — and black people specifically - assume their higher purpose. And so I don’t believe he’s a total “sell out.”
But I do believe that for Tavis, in the end, it’s a lot about posturing and achieving a personal goal of being a power broker. Yes, he hitched his wagon to the Clintons, but so what? Yes, he is a FREE BLACK MAN IN AMERICA, so he can make that choice.
He’s about to burn out now though, because he’s met his match. Barack Obama doesn’t need a Tavis Smiley. He’s beyond what Tavis could ever have done for him.
Now it’s time for Tavis to just back up and stop blocking.
Yes We Can!
February 21, 2008 at 10:40 am
The SOBU is important, but not at the cost of the presidentcy, why doesn’t Tavis
fly to where Barack is campaining and have a one on one for now, and then after the primaries have another forum setup. We as black people need to see what we can do for our self, all of the wealthy blacks that we have and so called leaders, step up and put your money and talents together and form banks and jobs in the black community.
Tavis, this is where you should be expending your energy. i know tom joyner does a lot, but get those type of folks together on a regular basis, to change the black horizon. IT IS EASIER TO CHALLENGE ONE PERSON THAT DOES NOT FIT YOUR MOLD, THAN TO CHALLENGE ALL OF YOUR WELL TO DO BLACK FRIENDS TO STEP UP. HAVE DIFFERENT SECTORS ALL OVER THE COUNTRY CREATING BLACK BUSINESSES. STATE OF THE UNION BLACK ENTERPRISE FORUM, SO WE CAN SEE TRUE CHANGE THAT WILL GET DOWN TO THE GRASS ROOTS.
February 21, 2008 at 2:13 pm
Travis is all talk. What has he and his cronies accomplished? They have been holding these conferences for years, TALKING about what we should be doing. You are all right. If he knows so much, why don’t he run for president. JUST TALK, TALK, TALK!!!
February 21, 2008 at 3:33 pm
I am not very shocked at Tavis’ haterism. Why do you think he ended up getting fired from BET. He was hatin on Bob Johnson, who by the way is just as ignorant as Tavis.
Tavis needs to Man UP! and find his own place in society. He does not speak for me. His responses are always riddled with “us” and “our”….speak for your #%#@ self. We don’t need Tavis telling us who to support….I believe in Senator Obama and Michelle and believe it or not Tavis, I was able to make up my own mind without your help.
Tavis really thinks that we are all ignorant and that HE was put on this earth to help all us ignorant folk see the light. Well I proclaim that my light shines on Obama and not Smiley.
February 21, 2008 at 4:00 pm
TAVIS JUST BOOTED OBAMA INTO THE WHITE HOUSE,THANKS TO HIS NEGATIVITY
February 21, 2008 at 11:51 pm
Tavis Smiley will always be one of my favorite people, someone I remember from “waaay” back when he started on the airwaves with “Just A Thought” , and came to speak for FREE to young men who were incarcerated with “just a dream” about a better life. For all that he has done to keep the Black Agenda and Convenant based conversations moving forward towards positive actions, we can be grateful.
It is no easy task to mobilize people of African descent across the many dimensions of our diverse intragroup identities, from the pulpit to Princeton with a sense of urgency and purpose. My only criticism is the disesteemable omission concerning Michelle Obama. Beyond “admiration and affection”, love for affirming Black women voices that need to be broadcasted more widely should have been a compelling enough reason to invite her.
Furthermore, it would have been a great demonstration of appreciation for the notion of complimentarity as well as an understanding of Queenship roles in African centered male-female relationship dynamics.
Yes, Michelle Obama has an esteeming, empowering “quintessential American story of overcoming” as Tavis rightfully described in his commentary. Moreover, however, Michelle Obama also has tremendous capacity to frame the issues embedded in the heart of this campaign and is the best person qualified to speak on behalf of Barak as well as represent him– body and soul wise.
Hopefully Tavis will be able to seize another historical moment and quickly repair an apparent rupture in confidence that some of the negativity flowing throughout this blog conveys.
Just another thought…
February 22, 2008 at 10:46 am
THANK YOU tAVIS FOR BENG THE BLACK PERSON WHO UNDERSTAND BEFORE WE GET ALL EXCITED , LETS HOLD THE PEOPLE WE WANT TO SUPPOERT ACCOUNTABLE, FAR TO MANY TIMES WE JUMP ON SOMEONES BAND WAGON JUST BECAUSE IT IS THE MOST POPULAR THING TO DO, I HAVE NOT ALWAYS BEEN A FAN OF YOURS, BUT ON THIS ONE I HAVE TO AGREE WITH YOU THE REASON WHY WE ARE IN THE CONDITION WE ARE IN , WE NEVER HOLD PEOPLE WHO LOOK LIKE US ACCOUNTABLE, MY PRAYER IS HE WINS BUT I HOPE THE BLACK PEOPLES STRUGGLE DOES NOT GET LOST IN THE MESSAGE
February 22, 2008 at 7:57 pm
OBAMA WANT,S TO BE THE PRESIDENT FOR EVERYBODY NOT JUST ONE RACE BUT EVERY RACE. MR.TAVIS SMIELY STOP HATEING OK.
February 23, 2008 at 4:34 am
Tavis Smiley is a jackass!
February 23, 2008 at 8:37 pm
I’m sure Smiley knew that Obama would probably refuse due to his campaign schedule.
What’s the urgency that Obama attend NOW all of a sudden?? Why wasn’t he invited last year or why can’t he come next year?
With all the attention focused on Obama, I feel Smiley just wanted a little for himself. Now that he has it…it’s probably not the kind he wanted.
Personally, I never thought Smiley was all that. He always struck me as being overly full of himself. This incident helps convince me I’m right.
February 23, 2008 at 10:06 pm
I find the whole discussion kind of curious. I do listen to the Tom Joyner Morning Show practically every morning on my way to work. Tavis has done some good work by bringing to the attention of the community issues that concern us such as poverty, health care, education, and the application criminal sentencing guidelines within the judical system in the United States. We have learned from Tavis that there are tremendous disparities among the races and income groups (which sometimes are practically synonymous) and how devastating an effect those disparities have had on our communites. We appear to lag behind other groups in all the positive indicators such educational attainment, finanancial as well as economic well-being.
Senator Obama, in his campaign rounds, has spoken about leading efforts to provide Head-Start programs, comprehensive and affordable Healthcare programs; in addition, he has proposed strategies to address the povery that has plagued inner city as well as rural communities. The work that he did in the Illinois legislature to correct some of the injustices inherent in the state’s legal system is notable in terms of his commitment to put social justice at the top of his political agenda when he becomes President of the United States.
So, what I find curious about Tavis’s tirades in the recent past is “WHAT ARE BLACK ISSUES” beyond the ones he speaks about in his commentaries, which, in my opinion, Senator Obama continues to speak about in his campaign rounds? Can Tavis be more specific?
I have respected and admired Tavis a great deal over the years. I think the brother means well, and I hope people don’t go down the path of questioning his commitment or his integrity.
Having said that, Tavis has said that Black people are over-represented within the population of Americans without adequate Healthcare resources; those without educational opportunities; along with those within or under the supervision of the correctional and criminal justice systems. I’m sure Senator Obama has his hand on the pulse regarding these important concerns that are typically in the domain of disenfranchised communities. Tavis should have no fear. Logically speaking, when Senator Obama gets the chance to fix those problems for all Americans, Black people would be over-represented among the ultimate beneficiaries.
Keep in mind that in one of the 19 debates between the Democratic candidates a question was asked as to whether they thought Dr. Luther King, Jr. would endorse any them for the presidency, Senator Obama’s response was that he didn’t think Dr. King would endorse any them. Instead, he thought Dr. King would hold each of them accountable. So, folks, Senator Obama knows about responsibility and accountabilty working hand-in-hand.
My good people, it’s okay for Tavis to take sides, The problem is when he attempts to sell as unbiased information, rather than pseudo-political commercials, his compulsive one-sided commentaries aimed at disparaging the hopes and aspirations of millions of people he claims to love. (He may not even be aware of the one-sidedness of his presentations of late.) Perhaps, Mr. Tom Joyner should consider looking for someone to present counter arguments to Tavis’s viewpoints, at least as far as Tavis’s commentaries on the on-going presidential campaign issues are concerned.
Hey folks, let’s be smart about this ‘thing’. Senator Obama has raised over $100 million in his campaign account. Let’s be real! All that support did not come from Black folks alone! And if Tavis is looking for empty promises, Obama is probably not his candidate - Any of the other presidential aspirants can fill the bill. Also, if Tavis is looking for a black-militant-card-carrying candidate, again, Senator Obama is not his candidate. That strategy simply doesn’t work!
February 24, 2008 at 1:18 am
Smiley is a tied-tongue, over-inflated-ego, faux black person who does NOT speak for me. It’s like he’s trying to single-handedly sabotage the one viable, highly-qualified candidate this country has seen in a very long time! I agree with others who have rightly described Smiley’s rant as a glorified hissy fit done for the purpose of trying to steal some of Senator Obama’s limelight. Tavis, go sit your behind in a corner somewhere - your in time out.
Great observation by another poster that one of Tavis’s corporate sponsors is the corporation of which Hillary is a former board member. Tavis, a sell-out to the Big Corp - in bed with the Clintons. This behavior and mindset is part of the old paradigm. Obama and the grassroot troops are part of the new paradigm. Tavis speaks out of fear - he and those like him know their days are numbered. Imminent extinction is a sobering experience.
February 24, 2008 at 2:20 am
Mr. Smiley, Get over it. Senator Obama is running for the OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICAN FOR ALL PEOPLE NOT JUST BLACK PEOPLE. He (Senator OBAMA) will have a place in the history books. He will be remembered for his GOOD WORKS. Question….WILL YOU???He has better things to do with his time than to come on your.. ONE SIDED BLACK PEOPLE ONLY SHOW. This letter was send to you by a BLACK SISTER…..
February 24, 2008 at 2:32 am
TAVIS…..NOTE TO SELF…..OPEN MOUTH INSERT FOOT…..Boy did I make myself look foolish to my own race…….
February 24, 2008 at 4:18 pm
This is incredible, I have never seen such crabbing in my entire life. Black people get a grip, you want to hate on Mr. Smiley now, say he’s got ego issues and this and that. However we don’t seem to recognize in the world of national media, we have very few voices that have crossed over to even be an integral part of the political and media arenas. Conservative talk radio dominates the air waves and influences millions of people daily with their policies and positions that do nothing for black America, yet with one little issue, we as blacks attack our own in front of the world. Y’all really need to read Mr. Smileys comments addressing this issue. What has he said that isn’t true? Is it not true that Mr. Obama wasn’t raised as the average Black American? How soon we forget how many blacks were saying he wasn’t black enough before many of you jumped on the band wagon.
Lets put this in perspective, alot of planning goes into the SOBU, just as it does for planning a political campaign, if you are holding accountable all the candidates to the same criteria, and you comment that you feel it’s a critical mistake for any of them to not attend, why should Mr. Obama be any different and if you are not allowing any substitute speakers for the other folk, why should it be different for Mrs. Obama. It’s damn if you do, damn if you don’t. I haven’t heard Mr. Smiley endorse any candidate, He suggest that we vote on the issues and not on race, is that not true?
We should stop trying to pull people down, look in the mirror folks, we all make mistakes, Mrs. Obama made one recently in her comments about America, Mr. Smiley has made many I’m sure and Mr. Obama, as brilliant as he is, will make them as well. It is okay for someone to respectfully disagree with a decision which is what Mr. Smiley did.
Now all you people who have blinders on and can’t see anything but real hate for Mr. Smiley and un-daunting admiration for Mr. Obama , if Mr. Obama was not able to continue in the race for whatever reason, or didn’t run, where would your support be? It’s interesting that prior to Mr. Obama, Mrs. Clinton was the over whelming favorite for Black America, Now all of a sudden, she is dirt and anyone supporting her is a hater, hmmmmm? I personally want Mr. Obama to win, but unlike many of you, I’m not willing to through a brother who has dedicated his life to the betterment of the African American community to the wolfs in the WHITE media!!!!!! Mr. Smiley is no more perfect than the rest of us, but he represents us well through his articulation, intelligence and understanding of our issues. Quit being such a bunch of CRABS!!!!!!
And here’s the transcript, just in case you don’t have speakers or Quicktime:
http://tavistalks.com/pdf/ts_obama_commentary_a.pdf
February 24, 2008 at 7:35 pm
This is Tavis and all of the Black Americans that claim they have studied or want their children to understand their Black/African History. We grew up saying “You need to know where your from to know where your going”. Tavis, with his ignorance is being arrogent about this whole thing. Let’s support his Presidency! All of those that are pulling for Hillery or saying he is not Black enough are not supporting Black History. Those should not envolve their children in Black History or Black studies, nor should you speak on Black History or the struggles, nor should you try to attach yourself to Martin Luther King on his strength of Black Pride or self worth. History is being made and your against it, your not supporting this history. You can’t even speak to your chlidren or thier childrens, children about Black History because you don’t really support Black History. Your the “House Niggas”. Let’s go tell Massa, let’s not support our Black intelliengent Black Brothers because we can’t show them we love our Blackness or our people and our community.
February 25, 2008 at 12:41 am
You never invite your battleship up the river. Your gathering was a fit for smaller gunboats such as yourself. Obama is fighting for all Americans. If he becomes president, that is when you present your issues and concerns to him. His job then will be to listen and address not only yours, but those concerns that are important to all Americans. As an African American president, there is a strong possibility that some African American issues that were ignored in the past might just receive a little more attention. Tavis, I listen to you often, I love you bro and the what you try to do for the black community, However, I must say that you are small fish and though inspirational, definately not influential. At least not beyound your syndicated audience. Know your boundaries bro.
February 25, 2008 at 12:50 am
I am a redneck from Missouri—and I have not voted in 18 years until now. Obama is bringing about a Movement –one that we have not seen since Martin Luther King Jr. and John F. Kennedy. This man is bringing people of all races together. Who is Tavis Smiley anyway—why does he think Obama needs to drop everything to run down to his “State of the Union”??? Hell, Obama is in the works of trying to give his own “State of the Union”—- in Washington!
February 25, 2008 at 2:27 am
I must agree with Mr. Travis Smiley, Black people still don’t understand the political game that is going on here in America. It call divide and conquer which is the same tacts that were use to get President Bush in office except now they are using a Black man the give you hope of a better America.The good old boys don’t vote in the primilary. There are more White folk in America than Black. I feel that Obama should have made the Black Union Forum. The company I work requested his present and he offered a video tape. He doesn’t support meanful Black function. I am voting for Hillary Clinton. I am Black female. She is better qualified to do a great job as President of the United State of America. When she is elected for President she will also be making history. This country is still racist and sextist. Women have the Power. Good Job Travis.
February 25, 2008 at 12:35 pm
I have a couple of points:
#1 To all those who question if people are voting for Sen Obama because he is black. Please remember that ALAN KEYS, who is also an announced candidate for the 2008 election, who is a Republican, and is also African American, is not receiving my vote, nor apparently anyone else’s in the Black community, regardless of whether the media gives him any play or not. I hope that ends the question of if anyone is voting for Obama because of his “blackness”.
#2 Personally, Hillary Clinton was not my pick for NY Senator, let alone President of the US, and if she was as black as the void from which we all come from it would make no difference to me. Professionally, I think she is a disingenuous carpetbagger, and always has been. She’s not my choice for President or Vice President, for that matter (and those that suggest that Clinton/Obama ticket would be an acceptable alternative I believe fail to recognize how that would not only handcuff Sen Obama, but negate the power of the constituency that has grown around him). As for the Tavis Tirade, I understand his spoken frustration as a promoter and pundit, but to dare suggest that Sen Obama isn’t concerned about “Black Issues” is insane. Let’s remember that he’s already been in the N.O. five times already, and that Mr. Smiley’s promotional company in and of itself is not the sole conduit of communication to African Americans, no matter where one’s political and cultural beliefs may stand. To pass on the opportunity to have Michelle Obama represent her husband at the forum is an extremely bad decision on Mr. Smiley’s part, politically and business-wise (would he have dome the same had Sen Clinton been unavailable and offered her husband as an alternative?). I generally consider Mr. Smiley’s programs a great asset to our community, however I find this decision disturbing on many levels, and definitely not based on the best self interest of the Black Union.
Jared Hassan Foles
Producer-World Eater Recordings
Co-founder/Guitarist-Shrine For The Black Madonna
http://www.worldeaternyc.com http://www.myspace.com/shrinefortheblackmadonna
February 25, 2008 at 3:52 pm
Thanks for revealing your true nature,Tavis. Bob Johnson fired you because he saw your true nature, which was self serving. (And by the way Bob is a self serving idiot as well). Its obvious that Hillary and her corporate partners( your sponsors) Walmart are all in this together. Tavis obviously has incentives from both of them to rally the black vote, which in itself is hipocritical. It should be about rallying for the real cause, not personal gain. Obama is kicking ass and will eventually win. If you and Hillary were really about Blacks and uplifting the nation , you wouldn’t be using the tactics that you are. You all would join the winninng team if you were about uplifting the race. Obama has a “Grass” Roots movement (and you know I like grass), and that’s why he’s winning. And who says grass doesn’t make you smart!(smile)
February 25, 2008 at 7:28 pm
FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO NEED TO KNOW ABOUT OBAMA’S ACCOMPLISHMENTS, here is a head-to-head comparison of the candidates’ accomplishments: Senator Clinton vs. Senator Obama
The following was forwarded to me by a friend.
—Subject: Re: Clinton vs Obama
Date: Sunday, February 24, 2008, 7:12 PM
Senator Clinton, who has served only one full term (6yrs.), and another year campaigning, has managed to author and pass into law, (20) twenty pieces of legislation in her first six years.
These bills can be found on the website of the Library of Congress (www.thomas. loc.gov), posted here as well.
1. Establish the Kate Mullany National Historic Site.
2. Support the goals and ideals of Better Hearing and Speech Month.
3. Recognize the Ellis Island Medal of Honor.
4. Name courthouse after Thurgood Marshall.
5. Name courthouse after James L. Watson.
6. Name post office after Jonn A. O’Shea.
7. Designate Aug. 7, 2003, as National Purple Heart Recognition Day.
8. Support the goals and ideals of National Purple Heart Recognition Day.
9. Honor the life and legacy of Alexander Hamilton on the bicentennial of his death.
10. Congratulate the Syracuse Univ. Orange Men’s Lacrosse Team on winning the championship.
11. Congratulate the Le Moyne College Dolphins Men’s Lacrosse Team on winning the championship.
12. Establish the 225th Anniversary of the American Revolution Commemorative Program.
13. Name post office after Sergeant Riayan A. Tejeda.
14. Honor Shirley Chisholm for her service to the nation and express condolences on her death.
15. Honor John J. Downing, Brian Fahey, and Harry Ford, firefighters who lost their lives on duty.
Only five of Clinton’s bills are more substantive.
16. Extend period of unemployment assistance to victims of 9/11.
17. Pay for city projects in response to 9/11
18. Assist landmine victims in other countries.
19. Assist family caregivers in accessing affordable respite care.
20. Designate part of the National Forest System in Puerto Rico as protected in the wilderness preservation system.
Facts straight from the Senate Record.
———— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ———
In her six years in the senate she has done ONLY 20 things.
———— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ———
OBAMA’S RECORD
Now, I would post those of Obama’s, but the list is too substantial, so I’ll just categorize them. During the first (8) eight years of his elected service he sponsored over 820 bills. He introduced
233 regarding healthcare reform,
125 on poverty and public assistance,
112 crime fighting bills,
97 economic bills,
60 human rights and anti-discrimination bills,
21 ethics reform bills,
15 gun control,
6 veterans affairs and many others.
His first year in the U.S. Senate, he authored 152 bills and co-sponsored another 427. These included:
**the Coburn-Obama Government Transparency Act of 2006 (became law),
**The Lugar-Obama Nuclear Non-proliferation and Conventional Weapons Threat Reduction Act, (became law),
**The Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act, passed the Senate,
**The 2007 Government Ethics Bill, (became law),
**The Protection Against Excessive Executive Compensation Bill, (In committee), and many more.
In all since enter the U.S. Senate, Senator Obama has written 890 bills and co-sponsored another 1096. An impressive record for someone who supposedly has no record according to the spin meisters and mindless twits. I challenge Clinton supporters to name a single legislative accomplishment that demonstrates her superior experience.”
Posted by: Mark | February 4, 2008 9:39 PM
While Mr. Obama has been working hard authoring, co-authoring Bills of great substance and change and making them into law, Hillary has been naming libraries, postoffices, and courthouses, etc.
These facts may not change your thinking and/or opinions, they have just been stated as a comparison.
February 25, 2008 at 8:43 pm
Tavis is out of line and very selfish. Obama is fully aware of the issues in Black venues, it is obvious Tavis is trying to be a kingmaker and he is acting like a petty fool…
February 26, 2008 at 1:58 am
I knew there was a reason I NEVER liked Tavis Smiley or is show. Now I understand why. Everyting must come to light. As always we have to make this a “Black” issue …why?
The man is busy running a campaigning. He “ain’t got time for you
Stop whining
Yes we can…with or WITHOUT you
February 26, 2008 at 4:17 pm
I was not about to get involved in this discussion until a friend encouraged me to do so. So, here are my thoughts:
I believe Tavis means well with this whole issue of “State of the Black Union”, but frankly, Tavis is not including every Black group in his “Union”. We are not a monolithic group of people. We have differing opinions and should not be made to believe that Tavis speaks for all of Black America and can bring us all together. Indeed, he has not brought us all together before and I don’t he can now. There are several Black organizations that are not represented by Tavis’ Union, so for him to claim that Mr. Obama’s refusal to attend his Union means he does not support Black issues is preposterous.
What is even sadder to me about all this, is that we will engage in such a long discussion over a whinny lad who is about his own commercial success and does include all Black issues in his forum. Did Tavis invite native-born Africans who are a part of the Black America mosiac to speak at his meeting? Did Tavis invite Black Latinos who are native or not native-born Americans to speak at his Union? The Black Issue in America has become very complex and to think that because one man who is doing his best to unite America did not attend the meeting can make or break our unity does not make sense to me. Can anyone voice speak for all of Black America? I contend, no. I think really that we have become a coalition of Black folk rather than one racial entity like we used to be in the mid to latter 20th century. We should stop believing that we are so defined by our race that we cannot have a difference of opinions and ideas.
Frankly, I believe Hillary attended the meeting herself because she is desperate to win and will stop at nothing to show that she represents Black folk, if our vote will help her win. If she cares so much about Black folk, let’s ask the Black people in NY State or city what she has done for them since she became their senator. Her husband located his office in Harlem to pretend he cares about Black folk, but how many Blacks work in the Clinton Foundation? What has happened to real estate prices in Harlem since the Clintons moved there? Have Black folks been able to buy and own property in Harlem? C’mon y’all…Hillary, Tavis, and their friends are playing politics and we are falling for it by engaging in this self-hating dialogue. If Hillary cares so much about Black folk, what has she done about Daffour or Rwanda or the Black folks whose businesses have been displaced in Harlem because her husband moved there? Has anybody checked property prices in Harlem lately? If Hillary cares so much about Black folk, how many times has she been down to New Orleans to help rebuild the lives of those who have lost everything because of Katrina? What has she done about Black folks in the delta region who lost everything? What legislation has she sponsored to help folks in Houston who have received the Katrina victims? What has she done about our children who are dying in Iraq? What about our children who are failing in our schools. If she is so experienced, what difference has she really made for our people?
I for one do not believe that Barack or Hillary will do so much for Black America as to change our basic position in America. Where I differ with Tavis is that at least, Barack offers me HOPE. Just like Kennedy offered HOPE. I want to support someone who is not an establishment candidate but rather someone who is outside of the mainstream enough as to give me HOPE that just maybe, my children will “live in an America where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character”. Isn’t that what Dr. King died for? Really, isn’t Mr. Obama exactly what Dr. King died for? Mr Obama should be judged by the content of his character, not by the color of his skin. And franky, color aside, he seems to represent my view of America a whole lot better than Mrs. Clinton or Mr. McCain. and that is why I am voting for him, and I urge you to vote for him as well.
February 27, 2008 at 12:51 pm
I think Tavis, like anybody else, is entitled to have their own view on political figures. He shouldn’t be attacked as hating or anything else. There are legit reasons to support one candidate versus another. To indicate otherwise seems counter to the entire “change” movement.
I, too, am black and support Clinton. I have my reasons. But an Obama supporter should be the LAST person on earth to criticize or be nasty about it. I, mean, doesn’t that go against Obama’s message of bringing diverse people together and changing politics?
February 27, 2008 at 5:02 pm
Soldierette… thankyou, thankyou..I went and read the brotha’s letter. I got it. I think he regrets greatly what he said and I don’t think he was telling the truth when he said “it was just an invitation, nothing more, nothing less”. However, I can’t stay mad at the brotha after reading that. I think his ego got the best of him for about a min. and now he’s back with us. God bless him….his letter pretty much closes the subject for me.
February 27, 2008 at 5:09 pm
Tavis, sit down somewhere.
February 27, 2008 at 9:53 pm
Tavis does not speak for most or all Black people. He tries too hard to be folksy with all that ain’t crap. He thinks to highly of himself and is one of the quinessential self appointed “black leaders” I applaud some of his efforts but he deosn’t speeak for me and many others. I am tired of the Tavis’ and Sharptons’s. The have anntoited themselves and their motivation in my opinion is more driven by their need to be seen.
Go Away Lil Tavis
February 28, 2008 at 2:00 am
I will like to know what Tavis has done to confront Walmart, a corporation with the worst record of employee treatment, exploitation of minorities etc. Wellsfargo is at the heart of some of the mortgage problems of minorities in America. These were the sponsors of Tavis Smiley. What about using Black peope to sell his books and exploiting the poor as usual. Let Tavis discuss the financial aspect of the annual SBU.
February 28, 2008 at 3:38 pm
I don’t think Tavis’ request was inconsitent with his aim to promote asking tough questions of decision makers and contributors to the social fabirc that is America. Yes Sen. Obama is busy but so are all the persons being invited to address this forum. Why are so many people accusing tavis of “hating” when in reality he is doing what many people don’ t want to do which is “stating” opinion and plans for the future. Just as I hold the American electorate responsible for the last 4 years of decline because no one listened to the answers W gave in the second election he promised more of the same and that’s what he delivered. Tavis is asking up front what is your plan to promote the Agenda of African Americans. Its OK to ask questions but its vital to listen to the answers. When someone says your forumn is not significant for me to address, well that’s an answer all in itself.
February 28, 2008 at 4:58 pm
When Martin was alive there were those “Knee-grows”who could not wait to tear him down, professing friendship and slipping a dagger into his back. As the late Ossie Davis pointed out in his marvelous eulogy of Malcolm, we did not recognize our “Black shining Prince” until it was time to lower him into the ground. Not just the fools who shot him, but mean spirited, jealous “darkies” and “hankerchief heads” who, because of envy and stupidity, would not abide with him. Now we have Barrack. Highly intelligent, happily married, an excellent father and one who has tried to give back to the community. He has been cast into high places by the will of the electorate. We have another Martin, who did not come by way of the cloth, but through politics. True to historical form, this white ass hugging slave, Tavis, attempts to tear him down. I hope you enjoy the company you are in, you dog.
February 28, 2008 at 6:28 pm
I don’t agree with the harshness that came from Tavis Smiley, my opinion, also I don’t agree with the harshness that is going back towards Tavis Smiley. I do believe that if you are pushing forward an agenda for the sake of black people with the “State of the Black Union”, one of the last thing you should do is to come after black people when they are unable to cater specifically to what you want. Obama is running for the presidency of the United States of America which includes people of all different colors, backgrounds and beliefs. There is no position for the hispanic president, there is no position for the asian or jewish president, there is no position for the woman president, there is only the one position for president. Also, Tavis needs to take a page from the book of Malcolm and Martin and realize that just because your approach may not be the same, does not mean that you’re not fighting for the same cause. Peace
February 28, 2008 at 11:00 pm
I love Tavis Smiley, however, I am very dissapointed in your behavior regarding Barack. I hope that you realize how selfish and childish you appear. I hope that you find it in your heart to apoligize to him, get over it, and move on to the next conversation.
February 29, 2008 at 11:01 pm
Yes, simply put: Tavis Smiley is jealous of Barack Obama. Travis may feel that Senator Obama was obligated to come because he is a Black man. We must grow beyond race. If other people can so can we. My goodness, he is running for the highest office in the land. If we cannot make comments to lift him up, we should not say anything at all. Be careful, this is history and it is being recorded for the next generation.
Tavis, I respect what you were trying to do on BET and for that I have always saluted you. Respect him and hold your pen and tongue as he should be celebrated. He knows who he is and he will not forget his people. He knows exactly where he is from and most of us don’t.
March 1, 2008 at 1:14 am
I never liked you and this is not helping to persuade me from my original position. How much is Hillary paying you to be her spokesperson?
March 1, 2008 at 9:43 am
Over the past years i have listen to Tavis.I am deeply dissapointed with him.
There is a time in this country for a change.I Support Senator Obama.
March 1, 2008 at 10:19 am
I watch part of the State of the Black Union each year since it has aired on television. I agree with the overall theme of the event, but not with the purpose. What I want to know personally, is why do we as African Americans need to gather to hear rich, intelligent, and well spoken leaders. I feel that instead of gathering to hera these leaders, perhaps those leaders need to gather us to solve problems. For example, unite us together to rebuild New Orleans, unite us together to get kids back to school, unite us together, to create jobs, and motivate us to be good parents, and how to keep your home,or even purchase one. I am personally tired of hearing speeches from all individuals and I am ready to work. If their job is to unite, motivate, and bring awareness to the state of the black union, solving some of the problems associated with African Americans would elevate the stste of the black union more than anything else.
March 1, 2008 at 12:19 pm
Who ever said that the panelists represented us. Let me quote the statement “Black thought-leaders, opinion-makers and influencers”. How many of the folk on the stage represent any form of job creation for blue and white collar black employees. There is talk rhyme, complaint, etc. However, until you can set a measurable and accountable plan of action that creates jobs and opportunities you haven’t done much more that b—- like the rest of the folk. I have watched many of the annual State messages that Tavis put on each year. It is inspiring for about 1 hour after the show goes off. I see and feel no visible action that represents substantive change for the Black Community. Talk without action that generates measurable results will not benefit us. Many of us have proven that we know how to talk, dress, and interpret the rules of the game, but it has yet to bring much in the way real results.
Please read the disparity study at http://www.blackamericancommunity.com and see what Blacks are not getting in Houston and in Texas.
March 3, 2008 at 11:09 am
I’m proud to have an advocate, like Tavis, to speak up for what he thought was right. It shows that we as blacks have independent minds and indepenent thought. Sometimes I wonder about that. obama doesn’t need Tavis he has the entire mainstream media behind him. So please let’s just try to muzzle him. Are white people trying to muzzle other whites who happen to be supporting Obama or McCain or Nader simply bc they are white?
That’s the problem. We want to appear as if we think for ourselves while behind the scenes we pressure black people to get in line, which is both dishonest and hypocritical.
Just because a black face occupies or potentially will wins a political seat or a place in leadership, it doesn’t mean that’s enough. We must hold them accountable. That’s why we end up with leaders in office who don’t do anything.
We are not just a race but a constiuency — just like labor groups, educators and so forth. There are specific issues that address our needs and views. Since when did black people not care about coming together and having an agenda? Since Obama? I hope not.
March 3, 2008 at 4:39 pm
My only question is “Where is all the HATE coming from, Tavis”? i have heard you say that you are only attempting to stick with the issues at hand and forgive me if know i have heard Senator Obama address the issues of black folk. There must be some deep seated issue and i pray that you give it to God and let the brotha run on!
March 4, 2008 at 1:42 am
Tavis, You didn’t have to go so hard… because you were upset… There are bigger things happening than the State of the Black Union. Your decision to deny his wife.. .I guess is understandable as you wanted “candidates” not spouses, but you cannot and you will NOT chastise Barak because he prioritized his time as HIS campain saw fit.
(Besides for the record, you need to learn to be flexible.. its a close race closer than its ever been… your past playbook doesn’t matter this time around… Michelle/Bill and whoever’s spouse would have MORE than sufficed).
Your behaviour was unnacceptable… these were the choises:
1. go back to N.O for the 6th time (and risk loosing the nomination if it was a close finish)
2. continue campaining and risk this stupid redicule.
He chose to gain ground in states hilary should win (she already lost one of her must win states “Wisconsin”) Texas and Ohio is next.
I like what I read above, Someone said we must hold black folks accountable like we do the Republicans when they miss black events… but more importantly black so called “leaders” (TAVIS) need to become smarter and realize that if a BLACK MAN, with a BLACK WIFE and BLACK CHILDREN can’t make it.. then the timing of this meeting probably is off and may need to be changed or there may need to be some flexibility… Use your heads…. The race is too close super tuesday a few months ago solved nothing…
If its still not clear then I bid you…
Dude get over yourself.. you Impressed me when you spoke in Seattle at a black event a few years ago, but your letter in response, your current attitude and your radio interview is making you into an a$$… this is bigger than YOU… relax and go sit down somewhere until this is over. One day someone will explain to you that the cause is bigger than the show.
March 5, 2008 at 7:03 pm
in my opinion,tavis was dead wrong in how he criticized barack for declining his invite to the SOTBU.if barack had accepted his invitation,would made his campaign look like he is favoring only african-americans to barack’s white suppoters and that would have been damaging to barack’s image and campaign.senater clinton only was there to try and make barack look bad by saying that barack wont even come and speak to his own people.
barack speaks to all people.and represents all american black,white ,hispanic,asian,arab,native american,etc.tavis is a great leader and representive for black people and has done great things for black people,and i commend him for it.but this time he is dead wrong for the way he went about resonding to barack’s letter.this is nothing but black folks tearing down other black folks or CRABS IN A BARREL.
get over it and go somewhere and have a good cry.barack had to plan and strategize for the primaries in texas and ohio,which is a big election to boost his candidancy for president of the united states of america.being president is a job that serves all people,no favorites.and OBAMA will address the issues of our black communities in the appropriate time and place,like he has done in the past.
March 6, 2008 at 9:23 am
I think that it is very sad that we criticize Tavis for having an opinion that differs from the consciousness of some African-Americans. Tavis is not a hater, but rather a passionate brother who has worked in the community to advance our cause just as Obama is attempting to do in this election. Instead of tearing him down and threatening to boycott him for a right we faught to aquire; freedom of speech, we should be admiring his committment and determination. As a people, we criticize other politicians if they fail to attend the NAACP or Urban League Affairs, but we reprimand Tavis for suggesting that Obama should make it a priority. A few hours at the Black Forum in Louisiana would have drawn the attention not just to the summit, but the forgotten atrocities which happened with Hurricane Katrina. He could have used it to help draw attention back to a city where African-Americans have been forgotten. Let’s stop criticizing each other and come together for solutions. We are a powerful people and a voice to be recognized if we stand together.
March 8, 2008 at 5:09 pm
Tavis, appears to have his pride hurt, because of that he is not hearing
Obama, or understanding his circumstances. It saddens me to see this
happen, knowing that Obama is being spread so thin. I’m sure he has
had to regrettfully decline other great invitations. He just can’t be every where.
We love Obama, and hope so see more racial unity. Tavis needs to “get off it”
Iowan’s for Obama
March 9, 2008 at 3:06 am
I am very disturbed by Mr. Smiley’s comments! First of all, instead of holding a forum to discuss the issues facing African Americans today, he needs to be holding a forum to discuss what WE can do as a people to address many of the demises we bring on ourselves. I have been an educator for almost 23 years. Most of my time has been spent working in inner city schools with poor children. I’m passionate about working with these children because their experiences parallel my own in many ways. I can assure you from my years of experience that there is alot that we can do to help ourselves and to break generational poverty. There’s just not enough room in this email to share the countless stories that have frustrated me through the years! I am disgusted and disappointed by the lack of involvement and commitment to the eduational process as a way out of poverty and racial disparity that exists in among many African-American people. Education is free in this country. We have a right to it and many of our people don’t even avail themselves of it and they don’t want any better for their children. Lord, help us! I interested in solutions to make things better, not forums to discuss the problem. This is a problem that is our own and we have to own it. Senator Obama is trying to affect change in the way that God has given him wisdom to do so. Is Tavis really listening to the message of the man???? I think not, because if he were, he would realize that Senator Obama does have a vision for our communities. I think his appeal and approach is to the masses. In order to have an impact on our community, he has to show how he will affect all disenfranchised people. This doesn’t mean that he has to be present at every discussion where we believe our important issues are being discussed. I’m really disappointed by Mr. Smiley’s comments and I am glad that he is not the voice of all African-Americans!
March 9, 2008 at 12:22 pm
How in the world would you consider Tavis Smiley’s response to Barak Obama’s decline, “hatin”? Go back read it carefully and seriously.
Mr. Smiley was as efficient as anyone could ever be in his letter. READ IT
March 11, 2008 at 8:46 am
I once respected and valued Tavis opinions. I have now lost respect for Tavis, because he is acting out of emotions.
Tavis is a brilliant respected man amongst many. He has the ability to reach and influence many. For him to go in front of the audience he has (which is mainly black) and say he is not happy or disturbed by Senator Barack Obama decision to reach all races and not just focus on the “black issues” is appalling.
We finally have a man who stands for “ALL” including blacks and happens to be black and Tavis points out all of his negatives, because he is not running the political campaign the way “Tavis” would want.
When will Tavis be satisified! There are going to be issues with everyone who runs for the presidency seat; however, we are closer to having someone who listens, understands and strategically applies our needs to those of the Congress.
March 11, 2008 at 1:26 pm
In view of the “Busy” campaigning season, Mr. Tavis Smiley could have been a bit more understanding by simply postoning the forum until and later date, say during the extended period in March before the Pennsylvania primary !
A little bit of understanding goes a long ways…… This is quintessentially, LOVE.
Any one with Love can’t help but be understanding with Senator Obama.
March 12, 2008 at 11:49 am
I have been paying close attension to the whole issue concerning Obama not attending the Black Forum. first of all this is not the time to bring anything negetive into play concerning Obama. My Mom used to say if you don’t have anything good to say. Don’t say anything. especially if your a person whom is seen and admired all over the country. If you don’t see that this man is concerned about not only the Black Community but the entire Community then you are deaf dumb and blind as a BAT! Tavis sit it down.
March 12, 2008 at 8:55 pm
It truly amazes me that when Tavis first talked about the “State of the Black Union” how many of our people thought that this would be our new mantra. Is it more important that the candidate is black than it is to speak on what the issues truly revolve around? Tavis, I hate to say it but it appears that “our” people only like you when you say what they want you to say. Continue to push the issues as you always have, and let the pieces fall where they may.
March 17, 2008 at 12:46 am
Since everyone is so quick to criticize Tavis, I wonder how many of you are going to do the same thing to Rev. Wright. It is a shame that we tear our own people down worse than any racist ever could. People should read Tavis’ response carefully and check his website for his feeling on the matter. He and Obama clearly know and respect one another. There is nothing wrong with two African-American men being passionate about pushing our cause to the forefront. Each of us has a different ideology as to the best route for elevating our people. We can support both of them without giving amunition to those who seek to keep us down. Pray for both of them and realize that no man is perfect. In your rush to make a statement on this issue, you are standing in judgement. If you believe in Senator Obama’s campaign then I’m sure that you know he would hate the devisise comments made and denounce the statements just as he has done in this campaign. He wants to bring this community together, not tear it apart. He is running on this agenda. Analyze his website just as vigorously as you have Tavis Smiley.
March 17, 2008 at 6:09 pm
This has indicated that Sen. Obama does not take side based on race. He is not for white neither is he for blacks. Obama is for the entire America. Travis like other racist fellows would love Obama to fall into the trap of siding with certain race. Obama is running for president of United State of America, he is not running to be a black leader or white leader. Obama sees things in a broad perspective and that’s why fellows like Mr. Smiley cannot understand the mission that Sen. Barack Obama has.
March 18, 2008 at 3:14 pm
WOW Tavis,
Seems that the real”SBU” (black individuals from all backgrounds, education, and wealth) have spoken. We have minds of our own and refuse to jump on this bandwagon that you expected us to. We are a people… not a person. We think very differently from one another and apparently from you too. Not to take anything away from the SBU, but to imply that maybe you were ‘blown off’ by BO and even emphasize that you never received any offer from BO to have his wife sit in in his place is (in my opinion) a slap in the face. Although you may not support BO, you don’t have to try and hold the man back. You tell me Tavis, what do your actions really do for the SBU? A MORE THAN WELL QUALIFIED black man runs for office and this is your best foot forward. You dont have to support him but you dont have to use your position and platform to tear him down. If the man said no, then let that be. Why make it a… ‘He must not care about us black folks’ issue? When you got the letter of decline from BO, you should have simply thanked him for his time and consideration and moved on. Let everything out of your mouth be about the issues.
April 11, 2008 at 9:35 am
I must say that even though Barack claims to be a candidate for all people, the fact that he did not attend the King memorial was shameful. I’m with Tavis on this, and you all should be too. I don’t want him to be a candidate just for black people, but the King Commemoration was an event that celebrated the life and legacy of a man that had a dream for all people. Even though I understand that he is campaigning, he should have taken just a little bit of time out of his busy schedule to be there. The white candidates did. I hate to say it, but are we really being objective when it comes to Obama. I like him too, but every ethnic group wants to know what the candidates’ intentions are when it comes to improving the quality of life for them, and there is nothing wrong with that. Tavis has always been a voice for people of color and I admire him for having the guts to display ideas that might not be popular, but that need to be explored. Please, let’s be objective people.
April 11, 2008 at 9:06 pm
MAKING THE DECISION
It was former Governor of New State, Mr. Carey, who once said: “If people tell you they are going to do something for you, first ask them what they have done.”
This is important because it goes to the core of the decision that each of us should make regarding which of the two Democratic Presidential Candidates (Senator Obama and Senator Clinton) will be a more effective leader of the free world – the United States of America.
In your decision-making process, consider “what they have done,” because what they have done, and continue to do, is a good predictor of what they are capable of doing in future.
Here is a good threshold test to determine who is ready and able to be “commander-in-chief” on day one. To start, let’s examine the following questions. Of the two candidates,
• In practical terms, whose campaign is financially in the RED, and whose campaign is debt free and continues to experience an expanding support base?
• Who is borrowing money from private sources to finance campaign spending?
• Who has raised the most money and has managed to keep expenses under control? (In February 2008 alone, Senator Obama has raised more money than the combined amount of donations received by Senator McCain’s campaign to-date).
• Which campaign is in apparent disarray and which one is quietly effective?
• Which of the two candidates has a greater capacity to instill a sense of selflessness and public service in the American people, while inspiring commitment and a sense of purpose in our youth?
• Who is better able to bring the American people together in order to reverse the erosion of the respect and greatness of this nation that has characterized the Bush Administration?
• Which of the two candidates is most prepared to lead the nation closer to a more perfect Union without the bitterness and rancor that is so prevalent in the politics of previous administrations?
• Who has the better judgment, along with the ability to respond to crises in a timely and effective manner?
• Whose political stand addresses the real issues and concerns confronting the American people?
• Who is really concerned about global peace - economically, environmentally and geo-politically?
• Which candidate is resorting to a political campaign of down-and-dirty tactics – a campaign of truth-shading and distortion, a campaign of character assassination and double-talk, a political campaign where the meaning of winning depends on what the definition of winning “is” – and who is being forced to respond to incomprehensible charges and politically-motivated accusations?
• Who is calm and deliberative under pressure? And who appears to be panicky and out of control, even when it is totally not called for?
Folks, the so-called ‘Kitchen-Sink’ doctrine came about because Senator Clinton’s people did run out of good ideas in terms of planning and executing a successful political campaign for national office. If they had a better approach, trust me, they would have tried it. Remember, people very often have a tendency to go to their best sources to seek solutions in times of crisis.
It is clear that Senator Clinton’s campaign is devoid of fresh ideas, of political depth and clarity. Additionally, Senator Clinton has demonstrated on numerous occasions that she does not perform very well under political pressure. She is prone to forgetting all about decency and what is proper any time she comes under stressful situations. Political expediency seems to govern the conduct of her campaign for the Presidency.
In deciding between the two candidates, it is imperative that you evaluate “what they have done” because the way Senator Clinton has run her campaign is the same way she would run the country, if she were to become the President of the United States.
The likelihood is that she will preside over a confused and a divisive Administration that run mountain budget deficits – the nation will witness a social, economic, and a political environment much the same as the one that has accompanied her political campaign. “You can’t teach an old dog any new tricks,” and so the adage goes.
April 13, 2008 at 9:21 am
WOULD I BE “BITTER” IF I LOST MY JOB AND MY HOME?
Am I hearing form Senator Clinton that individuals who are loosing their jobs and their homes as a result of the economic downturn are “happy” people? HMMMMM!
All I know is that Senator Obama has spent a lifetime working with less fortunate people who are confronted with economic frustrations and political disenfranchisement. Maybe, those are the people Senator Clinton knows; I personally have not come across such people in all my travels throughout the United States.
So, the idea that, suddenly, Senator Obama is “elitist” is pure bull crap.
April 14, 2008 at 7:20 pm
Thank you thegirlsays. It seems to me that every black person in the country jumps on the defensive everytime you even think about saying something even remotely negative about Barack Obama regardless of whether it is true or not. I want a Black president too. Believe me, I do. But, please explain to me why he can’t make appearances at events that simply discuss his intentions toward Black America. That does not make him racist or Pro-Black. I hate to say it but Hillary Clinton is running in the same race as Barack and she made both events. Again, I have to ask if we as a people are truly being objective.
April 16, 2008 at 1:57 am
I have lost all respect for Tavis Smiley. It’s really sad. The green eyed monstor has driven him crazy. His jealously of Senator Obama’s success is way over the top.
Even if Obama doesn’t win the election. He always be a better man than Mr. Smiley will ever be.
Tavis you need to go to church and get your heart right with God. Have you listened to the hate in your voice and comments whenever you talk about Obama.
I am a christian and wish you well….but I am no longer a fan.